Without a doubt Replay Museum [119 E Tarpon Ave, Tarpon Springs, FL 34689] is the best place to play pinball on the Gulf Coast.
You can leave the quarters at home and pay a one time price of $13 for full days admission. There are over 100 arcade games including dozens of pinballs ranging from old school to brand new.
Even with a good crowd playing, I could always find a game I wanted to play – there are so many choice machines!
Addams Family, Attack from Mars, Family Guy, Game of Thrones, Lord of the Rings, Space Jam, Spiderman, the Walking Dead, Twilight Zone, and Wizard of Oz just to name…well, a lot. But they are all so fantastic and you know I love pinball. 
Bonus? An amazing food option Eat Greek is right across the street, so you can play before dinner and after!